Yummy Recipes to Use Halloween Candy

Two yummy recipes that will use up some of that leftover halloween candy by Travel Parent Eat

Well, after tonight you’ll have loads (bucket loads, pumpkin shaped bucket loads) of candy sitting around.  Do you let your children eat as much as they want in one sitting, or do you make them ration it out over the next several days? Check out our tummy ache debate.  My oldest doesn’t eat much candy (don’t know how that happened, but I’m not complaining), and my youngest would eat the entire bucketful if I would let him.

One of my friends said she hides a bunch and places it in stockings at Christmas (as long as it isn’t black and orange, or pumpkin shaped). We finish trick-or-treating early, take out a bit that we want to eat and throw the rest into the dwindling candy bowl to pawn on the later trick-or-treaters.  This way we usually don’t end up with the candys we don’t like.  Who still gives out bit-o-honeys?  Actually, I save those and give them to my grandpa (good brownie points).

Whatever you do, you’ll probably have a couple of pounds of candy that will end up stockpiling.

Here are a couple of super yummy recipes to use a bit of that extra candy.

Starburst Candy Corn Rice Krispy Treats

Rice Krispy Treats made with Starburst Candy Corn and Cashews by Travel Parent Eat

Rice Krispy treats are awesome because they are so versatile.  You can pretty much throw anything with the cereal and marshmallows and it will turn out tasty.

I really loved how these turned out, and I don’t usually like candy corn.  My picky kiddo (the one who doesn’t eat candy) loved these.  I had to keep them on the back of the counter so my baby didn’t devour the entire batch!


1 Bag mini marshmallows

4 tbsp butter

1 tsp vanilla

6 c rice crispy cereal

2 c starburst candy corn (1 bag)

1 c cashews (raw, unsalted)


Melt the butter and marshmallows together.  Add the vanilla once the marshmallows are all melted.  Mix the cereal, candy corn and cashews together.  Pour the marshmallow mix over the cereal mix.  Stir until well combined.  Press into prepared 9 x 13 pan.  Allow to cool and set up.  Enjoy!

 halloween candy milky way cupcakes

The other yummy treat I have made (several years in a row) are the Milky Way Cupcakes and Frosting.  You use Milky Way (fun size, perfect for Halloween) candy bars in both the cupcakes and the frosting.  I originally found this recipe on a Paula Deen calendar (here’s the link to her site with the recipe), but I have adapted it both for elevation and for my preference (more chocolate, please).

Milky Way Cupcakes and Frosting

Cupcake Ingredients:

5 fun size milky way candy bars

2 tbsp butter

1 3/4 c cake flour (you can use all purpose)

1/2 tsp baking soda

1/2 tsp salt

3/4 c sugar

1/3 c oil

1 large egg

1/2  c plus 2 tbsp buttermilk

1/2 tsp vanilla extract

1/4 tsp almond extract

1/4 tsp orange extract

*You can just use 1 tsp vanilla if you don’t have all the flavorings

Cupcake Instructions:

Preheat oven to 350.  Place liners in pan.  Melt the candy bars and butter together (in the microwave, on 50% for 30 seconds, stir, repeat until smooth).  Sift the flour, soda, and salt.  In the mixing bowl whip the sugar and oil.  Add the egg.  Alternately mix in the buttermilk and flour mixture, starting and ending with flour.  Stir in the melted candy bars and flavorings.  Spoon into cupcake liners.  Bake for 15-18 minutes.

This makes about 15 regular-sized cupcakes.

Frosting Ingredients:

3 fun-size milky way candy bars

1/2 c plus 3 tbsp butter, divided

1 3/4 c powdered sugar

1/4 c cocoa powder

1 tsp vanilla extract

1/2 tsp almond extract

2 tbsp chocolate caramel coffee creamer (or just milk, or chocolate milk), adjust to desired consistency

*I always double any frosting recipe so I can add lots to the top and have some left over.
Frosting Instructions:
Melt the candy bars and 3 tbsp butter.  In the mixing bowl, whip the butter until light and creamy.  Add the powdered sugar and cocoa powder.  Mix until well combined.  Add the melted candy bars and whip.  Add the flavorings and milk and beat on medium for about a minute.
 Is there a Halloween candy you want a recipe for?  What extras do you always have?
Here’s one more super yummy recipe at Rachael’s other site, Eazy Peazy Mealz, Butterfinger Rice Krispy TreatsDoes that candy bowl look familiar? :-)
anne signature

About Anne Banks

Hi, I'm Anne! I am an active learner on this crazy road called life. I love learning about anything, but currently spend most of my study time researching parenting tips and improving health. I get excited about crafting, reading, running, baking, and spending time with my three crazy boys (in no particular order, and sometimes at the same time)! I love sharing what helps me get through the day, and I hope my tips help you!

, , , , ,

3 Responses to Yummy Recipes to Use Halloween Candy

  1. memoriesbythemile October 31, 2014 at 2:59 pm #

    Great idea for that left over candy, Especially like the milky way frosting. Pinned all three.
    Wanda Ann @ Memories by the Mile

    • Anne Banks November 2, 2014 at 3:13 pm #

      Wanda, thanks for visiting and sharing!


  1. 5 Tips for Better Gingerbread Houses | - December 12, 2014

    […] used mini candy canes, jelly beans, peanut m & ms, colored sugar, dots, starburst candy corn, and pretzels for our decorations.  We were going to use sugar cones as Christmas trees, and even […]